Author: Serwaa Manu
10/28/2024
The Electronic Benefits Transfer (EBT) system plays a critical role in providing essential resources to millions of Americans who rely on government assistance programs. Designed to enhance accessibility and streamline the distribution of benefits, this system has met with both praise and criticism. As a Justologist at the University of Justice, I seek to analyze the EBT system from an ethics and justice perspective, focusing on access and accountability. Recent incidents of fraud, such as the arrest of a supervisor at the Rhode Island Department of Human Services for benefits fraud, highlight the urgent need for reevaluation. This paper proposes innovative features aimed at enhancing the integrity and overall efficiency of the EBT system.
To improve the EBT system's effectiveness in delivering benefits fairly and transparently, it is necessary to integrate new features such as Visa or MasterCard payment options, fraud alerts, enhanced electronic access, and increased convenience for individuals with disabilities. Furthermore, all stores selling food should be mandated to accept EBT as a condition for operation, enhancing access for beneficiaries and tightening accountability within the system.
Disadvantages of the Old System
The current EBT system is not without its flaws. Several disadvantages have emerged, particularly in the areas of accessibility, security, and consumer rights.
Limited Payment Options
Beneficiaries are often restricted to using EBT cards at specific locations, which can be inconvenient and stigmatizing. These limitations not only affect the ability of recipients to purchase necessary items but also perpetuate social stigma surrounding the use of government assistance.
Fraud Vulnerabilities
Incidents of fraud, such as the reported case involving the Rhode Island DHS supervisor, have raised questions about the system’s ability to safeguard against abuse and misuse. Weak detection and prevention measures have created an environment where fraudulent behavior can flourish, undermining the integrity of the program.
Access Barriers
Individuals with disabilities sometimes face challenges navigating the current system, limiting their ability to utilize benefits effectively. Features that are not designed with accessibility in mind can create systemic barriers, making it difficult for all beneficiaries to utilize their entitlements.
Inadequate Accountability
Existing oversight frameworks may not be robust enough to detect or prevent fraudulent behavior, diminishing trust in the program. Lack of transparency and accountability mechanisms can lead to misappropriation and mismanagement of resources meant for needy populations.
Proposed New Features
Integration of Visa or MasterCard
Introducing Visa or MasterCard as payment options within the EBT system would significantly increase accessibility for beneficiaries. This change would allow recipients to use their benefits in a broader range of stores, navigate potential stigma, and foster economic inclusion. By providing more familiar payment options, we can help eliminate the sense of otherness that often accompanies benefits usage.
Fraud Alerts
The capacity to receive fraud alerts would bolster accountability within the EBT system. By proactively notifying beneficiaries of unusual transactions or potential fraud, this feature would empower users to protect their benefits and effectively report irregularities. Such a mechanism could not only deter fraudulent activity but also give recipients greater control and awareness over their resource allocations.
Enhanced Electronic Access
Improving electronic access to benefits would simplify the process for beneficiaries—a crucial step to ensure all individuals can obtain necessary resources conveniently. This could include a user-friendly app or web portal that allows recipients to manage their accounts, view transactions, and locate participating retailers. Enhanced access will ultimately aid in creating a seamless experience for users.
Convenience for Individuals with Disabilities
Creating an inclusive environment for individuals with disabilities is paramount. Enhancing the EBT system through initiatives that simplify access and usability—such as voice-activated technology or tactile interfaces—would ensure that all beneficiaries can navigate the benefits they deserve. Prioritizing accessibility reflects a commitment to justice and equity for marginalized populations.
Mandatory EBT Acceptance for Food Retailers
Reforming policies to require that all stores selling food must accept EBT as a condition for their operations would eliminate barriers to access for beneficiaries. This policy shift would ensure low-income individuals have sufficient purchasing options, thereby raising their standard of living and supporting local economies. This measure would further embed the principles of justice and fairness in the distribution of resources.
Benefits to the American People
Implementing these proposed features would yield significant benefits to American society:
Increased Economic Inclusion
More payment options would empower beneficiaries economically and reduce the stigmatization associated with using EBT. Access to diverse retailers would enhance beneficiaries' purchasing power and foster community engagement.
Enhanced Security and Trust
Fraud alerts and greater accountability measures would strengthen the integrity of the program and reinforce public confidence. Knowledge that there are systems in place to protect benefits aligns with the principles of justice and right to fair treatment.
Improved Accessibility
The system would become more user-friendly, ensuring that all demographics, including those with disabilities, could easily access benefits. This advancement is necessary for creating a just society where all individuals can thrive.
Consumer Rights Protection
By adhering to privacy and consumer laws, these adjustments would promote the rights of all beneficiaries, ensuring their data and benefits are protected. Upholding beneficiaries' rights is foundational to maintaining an ethical society.
Laws and Regulations
Integrating these new features would also necessitate compliance with existing laws and regulations:
Privacy Laws: Safeguarding recipients' personal information must remain a priority, ensuring data security through all digital improvements.
Consumer Laws: Implementing vendor compliance standards would protect beneficiaries' rights, ensuring they have access to fair services.
Rights of Individuals with Disabilities: Adhering to regulations that protect the rights of individuals with disabilities will be critical to promoting equity within the EBT system.
As a Justologist at the University of Justice, I argue that the Electronic Benefits Transfer system necessitates a comprehensive reevaluation to address issues of access and accountability. By integrating new features such as Visa or MasterCard compatibility, fraud alerts, enhanced electronic access, and increased convenience for individuals with disabilities, alongside enforcing mandatory EBT acceptance among food retailers, the EBT system can better serve its intended purpose. This evolution is not merely a technical upgrade but a step toward realizing a fairer and more equitable society for all Americans.
References
12 News Reporter Alex Torres-Perez. (2024, September 10). Supervisor at Rhode Island Department of Human Services Arrested for Benefits Fraud. WPRI 12 News. Retrieved from https://www.wpri.com/
Manu, S. (2024.). Justology. Retrieved from www.justology.us
University of Justice. Retrieved from www.universityofjustice.edu
Comments